Featured Posts

The Last Hurrah of 3 We've been trying to get away for an extra long weekend FOREVER now. With what's been going on in our lives for the past year, we actually would need something along the lines of a 12-employee-manned...

Read more

Why I can't watch Bringing Home Baby anymore [caption id="attachment_160" align="aligncenter" width="248" caption="From the Motherwear Breastfeeding Blog"][/caption] Ever since I can remember, I've been a fan of TLC's programming. When I was in...

Read more

Trust I'm learning a lot about myself lately. I don't know if it's the pregnancy or what, but I'm coming to terms with some facets of my personality, parts of my emotional IQ, that I didn't realize needed tending...

Read more

A little bit about me My old school polaroid creation Originally uploaded by amelie522 The picture. Let me explain the picture. My husband (god bless his camera-illiterate heart) took this picture. And 89098...

Read more

What I learned at BloggyBootCamp Bloggy Boot Camp. I don't even know where to start. It was so much good, so much happy, so much fun. I fully expected to be in awe of the speakers, as well as their brilliant commentary on social media,...

Read more

Why I can’t watch “Bringing Home Baby” anymore

Posted by amelie522 | Posted in All posts, because I don't have enough to categorize yet | Posted on 09-07-2010

18

From the Motherwear Breastfeeding Blog


Ever since I can remember, I’ve been a fan of TLC’s programming. When I was in college and idealistic and cheesy, I loved “A Wedding Story”. I probably cried at every episode, meanwhile critiquing everything from the bride’s choice of dress to her choice of dress for the bridesmaids. Apparently I’m very judgmental when it comes to bridal fashion, why I have no clue.

Then I reached that point in my life where I was looking forward to having babies. Once I met Papa, I wanted to create babies with him in the kinds of quantities you’d find in the Oriental Trading Company catalog (you know how you can get mini plastic kazoos in a quantity called a “unit” which is actually like 9879897 of them?) In order to appease this insatiable appetite for children, I started watching and DVRing every single episode of Bringing Home Baby, Birth Day, Babies: Special Delivery, Adoption Stories, and A Baby Story. It required much memory on the DVR and it spanned several channels. Poor Papa had this terrified, slightly nauseated look on his face upon reading the programs that were filling up the queue. That’s not really true…I just said it for comedic value. Papa wanted babies from the get-go. He would’ve impregnated me on our first date if he could have. Actually….it wasn’t too much longer after that I was indeed knocked up! But I digress….

Back to the baby shows. Until I had actually given birth to a real, live baby, I thought what was on those shows was probably pretty close to accurate. Obviously I was horrendously wrong. BUT after having a baby and breastfeeding that baby, I realized that the BIGGEST misconceptions that were being perpetuated and spread among new moms and moms-to-be because of these shows were those regarding the logistics and BASIC FACTS about breastfeeding a baby. Every single time I watch these shows I am painfully more aware of how they are spreading dangerous misinformation about breastfeeding. I have so many questions to ask these moms:
1) Have you EVER read anything about breastfeeding…ever? 2) Where did you come up with some of the ideas you have about breastfeeding? 3) I mean really, did you even read the pamphlet that they gave you upon leaving the hospital?

It has really started to upset me.

So this post is for all of those moms-to-be that watch those shows and take the information coming from the mouths of these new moms to heart. Because most, but not all of them, have no freakin’ clue what they are talking about. I’m going to clear up the 3 most common misconceptions that are being thrown out there by the moms of “Bringing Home Baby”:

1. Mom says this on day 2 post birth: “Well, my milk hasn’t come in yet so the baby isn’t getting enough to eat so we’re just going to supplement with some formula until my milk comes in.” WHAT? The suckling action of your baby stimulates the breast to produce milk. And your milk usually doesn’t come in, on average, until around day 4-5 post birth – but the baby isn’t hungry anyway; the colostrum is ALL YOUR BABY NEEDS until your milk actually comes in. By giving the baby formula and not allowing your infant to suckle on your breasts, you are inadvertently doing exactly what you’re trying to avoid: low milk supply. New babies are prepared for birth and the initiation of breastfeeding with an extra supply of fat to convert into energy, that’s why they lose weight after birth. The baby’s body is primed for colostrum ingestion only.

2. Mom: “The baby is having trouble nursing because he keeps falling asleep at the breast, so we’re just going to give him a bottle because we don’t want him to starve.” At this point, I’m spewing venom at the television and screaming at this exhausted, uninformed new mom and hoping against hope that she can hear me in TV land. BABIES FALL ASLEEP AT THE BREAST A LOT IN THE FIRST FEW WEEKS. Heck, they fall asleep a lot doing everything in the first few weeks. To keep baby up and alert during feedings, take off the blanket or swaddle, strip them down to the diaper if need be (that’s what we had to do with Henry), and rub their back or tickle their toes. This is so common among nursing infants it’s ridiculous. AND THE BABY IS NOT GOING TO STARVE. As long as you’re getting wet and dirty diapers during the day, you’re good to go.

3. “The baby nursed nonstop all night and most of the day yesterday, so it’s obvious that my milk hasn’t come in yet and the baby needs to eat. We’re just going to give her a bottle.” (Standing in front of the television and throwing the pieces of my breast pump at the new mom, while karate-kicking the air over and over again.) Babies that nurse eat a lot more than formula-fed babies! Breastmilk is baby’s perfect form of nutrition, therefore it is perfectly, efficiently processed by baby’s digestive system. That means it goes through the little one very fast. Which means she’s going to be hungry much sooner than you think! The thing about this fact is that it is not widely publicized; I’ve read pretty much every nursing book on the market and even some old, obscure ones, and only a few have actually stated that new babies nurse a whole heck of a lot more than you think. More than the “every 2-3 hours from beginning of a session to the end” that is recommended by said breastfeeding literature. Even though babies are SUPPOSED to nurse every 2-3 hours, it is more common that they eat closer to every 1 1/2-2 hours. (And when they “cluster feed” it’s more like every hour.) I know, it seems like a lot. But once those precious times are over, and your little one is way more interested in crawling around, and they nurse in record time, you’ll miss these moments. TRUST ME. And once again, you produce more milk the more you nurse, so if your baby is nursing a ton, you are building your supply for the baby. Stopping feedings because you think you don’t have enough breastmilk is completely counterintuitive!

All in all, it really boils down to this: just keep nursing. It may seem like your little succubus must be draining every last ounce of fluid from your body, and there is no way you have anything left to give. But you do. And your breasts are never truly “drained” or “empty” anyway. When a practitioner refers to emptying a breast, they are speaking of having the baby go through both the foremilk and hindmilk completely. See, even if you feel like your breast is empty, the baby is still getting milk if he’s eating and seems satisfied. Yes, babies DO use your breasts as pacifiers sometimes (we’ve dealt with that too). But even if they do, it’s nothing but good for you because it’s further building your supply which is what you want. I missed being able to comfort Henry in that way once I stopped nursing. I longed to be his binky again.

IF YOU ARE HAVING PAIN, OR IF BABY DOES NOT SEEM SATISFIED AFTER A FEEDING (I.E. CRYING, ARCHING BACK AT BREAST, BABY IS NOT RELAXED/LETHARGIC, NO PEE OR POO, ETC.) OR SEEMS DEHYDRATED, CONTACT A LACTATION CONSULTANT! I know there are problems with breastfeeding for some women, and I know it is hard. It wasn’t hard for me (what a blessing), but I am well aware of how difficult it can be for some women. But so many of the issues that nursing mothers talk about ARE very common and not a reason to stop breastfeeding. In fact, as I’ve stated many times in this post, discontinuing breastfeeding in most instances will create the exact problem you’re trying to avoid. I’m not a nursing lunatic, but I know that lots of new mothers desperately want to breastfeed and end up throwing in the towel based on things they see on these shows. And that is so unfortunate. Nursing is such a joy, once you get it right. And hey, if you just don’t want to breastfeed, that is totally fine and your choice. I’m not trying to convince anyone to do something they just do not want to do. I just wanted to clear up some of the lies that these shows perpetuate.

The reason I wrote this post is because I nursed my first, and he latched on in the delivery room which led my nurses to call me “the natural”. Little did they know, I had taken every class, read every book, and went to La Leche League meetings just so I could get to that point (and even all of that effort could have led to a rocky start anyway). I stopped earlier than I would’ve liked to, and I regret that to this day. Once I quit, I realized how much I truly loved nursing Henry. I tried relactation, but he just laughed when I tried to put him back on the breast, and that was only a week after we’d stopped. I had plenty of milk, he latched on well, but he used me as a pacifier and it kind of annoyed me. He had a fussy period, like every baby/toddler does during the day, and he nursed a lot during that time which I didn’t realize was very common. Now, at 4, there’s nothing I wouldn’t give to go back to me then and tell myself, “Let him use you as a comfort. Soon, he’ll want daddy more and you’ll be the second banana.”

So that’s it. WOW, that might be the longest post I’ve ever written. It was really important to me to get this out on the blog. It feels good to let other mamas know that the stuff about breastfeeding, specifically, that you see on those shows is sometimes very WRONG. And somewhere, deep down, I feel like at least my experience can be used for the greater good…however small it might be. I’m feeling all “charitable” now….can I get some sort of breastfeeding awareness award or something? Or smartest woman alive award? Anyone?

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • RSS
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • StumbleUpon

Comments (18)

I can’t watch those shows either- they usually do make me sad and upset at how “un-natural” they usually go. This is a great post, though. I agree with it all! :)

Steph
Adventures In Babywearing´s last [type] ..the dreams that you dream of

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Adventures In Babywearing, I’m so glad you agree! It really DID start to upset me, especially when so many of them women were presenting these ideas as factual. It made me so sad to think that people were actually listening and acting based on this misinformation. Thank you so much for commenting, Steph :) It really means a ton to me.

[Reply]

I just adore you …… and yes, I think you are a breastfeeding lunatic, since you are JUST LIKE ME!!

Brett was amazed by how much reading I did about breastfeeding when I was PG with Rachel. He said, “But breastfeeding is natural!” I know — it’s natural, but not always easy with the amount of misinformation you get from people.

You ABSOLUTELY have to have a strong resolve, and a support system is key to success. So many times, I wanted to throw in the towel, with cluster feeding TIMES TWO, growth spurts, and the like. My husband was paramount in the success of my nursing relationship of all three littles.

I’m in the process of weaning the boys now, and I’m not sure who’s going to have a harder time — them, or me. You’re so right — there are days where I am so OVER being the human pacifier to two BIG boys; but then I read posts like this one, and I want to go on forever.

Thanks for this post, and I’m looking forward to seeing you in just a few days!

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Dianna Kennedy, Dianna, you KNOW ME SO WELL!!! I am, in fact, a total breastfeeding lunatic. And I have to tell ya, the fact that you’ve nursed those boys for so long is a total inspiration to me! You brought up such a valid point: support is CRUCIAL. I am so excited to see you, I can’t stand it. I just love you to pieces. And this weekend is going to be so much fun! See you in a few days! xoxoxo

[Reply]

Tricia…I chose not to breastfeed but I have seen MANY of those shows and wondered why the women all seemed to throw in the towel after trying a couple of time…you’ve cleared that up for me so I vote for you to get the breastfeeding awareness award!! Congratulations!! On another note, I would love to meet Henry sometime soon and of course your new baby soon to be born…what a great mom you are!! We love you and miss you!! XOXO

Heather

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Heather Marchand, Hi Heather! I would absolutely love to see you soon. And I’m so excited that you vote for me for the award!! I think that means I automatically get it, because you’re my cousin and family overrides every other vote :) I will email you my phone number. Please call! I love and miss you guys! Thank you for your kind words.

[Reply]

Hi! I’m SO glad I found your site. I totally agree… moms on TLC (and all moms) can be SO naive. I literally had a friend a few years ago who didn’t breastfeed because her baby didn’t latch… the FIRST time. Like 20 mins after she was born. Anyway, I’m a HUGE lactivist which is kinda funny because I’m not an activist about ANYTHING… but that. Anyway, thanks for the great info!

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Erin, Hi Erin! I’m so glad you found me too! I’m a huge lactivist without much activism elsewhere in my life as well…I guess boobs that can squirt milk just get me going! I’m pretty eco-crazy, but not as much as I am breastfeeding crazy. Thank you for coming by and commenting :)

[Reply]

This is all great info – you’re right, those shows are horribly misleading. I gave up nursing after three weeks – mostly because the hospital screwed us up before we ever got going – insisting she wasn’t eating enough (when she just wasn’t hungry yet). Then I got PPD and…well, it just sucked.

If I ever have another, I’m going to try a lot harder.
amber´s last [type] ..Head- Meet Butt

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@amber, Hey Amber! Thanks for coming by and commenting. I appreciate the love, man. And I gave up nursing earlier than I would’ve liked (7 months) so I understand. But there are legitimate issues that can occur and hospital staff is just one of the many. PPD is a whole other monster, and your health is FIRST PRIORITY otherwise you can’t possibly mother a child well. I say you did YOUR BEST, and that is all anyone can do. Thanks again, and come back soon…can’t promise anything will be here, but hey, that’s what it means to be going back to my roots!! I loved your post about that, by the way :)

[Reply]

It is so sad to say this, but after watching my sisters’ failed attempts at breastfeeding, it seems that TLC shows aren’t the only thing perpetuating these breastfeeding myths. Doctors and nurses do, too.

One of sisters was pushed to supplement with formula before she even left the hospital, because she and her baby were struggling with latching at first. I couldn’t even believe that. My sister fought it, but finally gave in because they convinced her that her baby was starving. IN THE FIRST TWO DAYS.

She continued to try to breastfeed, but of course once she opened that can of formula, it was all over for both of them. She couldn’t understand why her milk supply wasn’t increasing. I knew EVEN THEN that it was a basic problem of supply and demand. She was leaning too much on formula and sabotaging her milk supply all because of advice she received from medical professionals before she even left the hospital. They told her it’s okay to supplement with formula in the beginning until your milk supply increases. But if you’re supplementing with formula from the beginning YOUR MILK SUPPLY WILL NEVER INCREASE. Ugh, so frustrating.

Now that I’m pregnant and planning to breastfeed, I’m hoping I won’t face the same issues. I have a natural birth friendly midwife, and I’m delivering at a “baby-friendly” hospital with lots of resources and education opportunities for breastfeeding, so I’m hoping they’ll be able to give me GOOD advice instead of prematurely pushing formula.
Karen´s last [type] ..Tick tock

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Karen, Hi there, Karen! So happy to see you came by to read and comment. I’m grateful and thrilled! I’m SO HAPPY you are prepared for what may happen at the hospital. Although the hospital may be “baby-friendly” or “breastfeeding-friendly”, watch out for those individuals that will try and push their PERSONAL opinions on you. But you don’t need me to tell you that; you’ve got all the information and ammunition you need to fight the “booby traps”! You sound exactly like I did before I had my first, and that means you’re setting yourself up for success. Even if you do encounter problems, just keep going! UNLESS, of course, baby isn’t thriving; he has bloody stools; diaper rash that leads to bleeding; dehydration; excessive crying, gas, pain; etc. My friend Nic over at “My Bottle’s Up” went through an awful time with her first; he was viably allergic to breastmilk, and it was really bad. People just kept telling her to forge onward, but she had eliminated everything from her diet and still her little man was NOT WELL. There are times when baby is allergic, but thankfully, it’s not very common. It’s not unheard of though, so make sure you’re armed with that knowledge as well. I failed to put that in my post, then I felt awful after thinking of Nic. But you’re going to be JUST FINE! Congrats, and keep me posted!

[Reply]

Great read, your so right about all these things, I’ve had so many friends come to me with the same issues, I just say keep nursing, nursing, nursing. And drink tons of water, of course I nursed twins for 8 months, so they though I knew it all, but I had every single one of those issues, with my preemie boys, but I didn’t give up and they soon became nursing champs, and at the end my body produced 18 oz every 3-4 hours. I knew this because I had to pump while I was at work, and never had to supplement with formula. I did what I had to do, and it was hard, time I wanted to give up, but I am glad I didn’t.

I always find it odd when a mother choosing not to nurse, like it’s unnatural or something. But if her dog had puppies would she take them from the mother and bottle feed them?
Jenna @ Newlyweds´s last [type] ..Fall Garden planted

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Jenna @ Newlyweds, Hi Jenna! So wonderful to see you here, and thank you so much for reading and commenting. You nursed twins for 8 months?!? Okay, you are officially my breastfeeding hero! You also overcame breastfeeding issues in addition to tandem nursing twins, so to you I say, BRAVO! I completely agree with your sentiment regarding choosing not even to TRY nursing. It’s so unfortunate, because those mothers will never know what they missed out on, and their children will have missed the benefits. Thanks again for your great comment, and please come back soon!

[Reply]

heck yes u get the smartest woman alive award! i wish this post could be read by every expecting mother there ever was! i too educated the crap out of myself while pregnant withcorbin and i would get so pissed watching those shows too! like screaming at the tv!! once i mentioned an episode to my midwife and she was like, noo dont ever watch that show! haha anyways, i knew i liked u! and this post (along with all the rest ive read so far totally proved it) :) so happy to have found your blog!!!

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@jill, that is too funny because I found myself literally YELLING at the ladies on the show, too! I’m so very happy you read the blog and liked it, and commented! Because I’ve been such a long-time reader of yours, but I just get really intimidated when it comes to commenting on a blog that has lots of readers (like YOUR amazing blog!). Anyway, so glad I’m not the only one that hates those shows now!

[Reply]

I sometimes use it as a teaching experience for my kids. I’ll watch it and tell them what the parents are doing wrong (primarily when it comes to breastfeeding) and explain why I think it’s wrong. I can predict with 100% accuracy whether or not the mother will still be BFing at the end of the show!

[Reply]

amelie522 Reply:

@Melodie, ME TOO!

[Reply]

Write a comment

CommentLuv badge